Studio vs Outdoor Headshots: Why I Recommend the Studio

Table of Contents
- Key takeaways
- Lighting: The Biggest Difference Between Studio and Outdoor Headshots
- Harsh sunlight vs soft studio light
- Controlling shadows, and why studio light flatters the face
- What studio light does for skin tone
- Does Weather Unpredictability Actually Cost You?
- Weather control in the studio
- Clothing Options: Why the Studio Gives You More Choices
- What to wear for a studio headshot
- Background Options and What They Say About You
- Why Consistency Matters More Than You Think
- The Studio Is Easier If You Dislike Being Photographed
- Which Setting Fits Your Professional Goals?
- Studio vs outdoor headshots by professional goal
- How Pricing and Session Structure Compare
- What to Ask a Photographer Before You Book
- Studio Headshots in Chicago at Aviva Sherman Photography
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Are studio headshots better than outdoor headshots?
- Is studio lighting more flattering than natural light?
- What should I wear for a studio headshot?
- Do studio headshots look stiff?
- Is a studio session a good choice if I hate having my picture taken?
- Where can I get studio headshots in Chicago?
- Can you match a team's headshots when we add new employees?
- Who pays if an outdoor session is rescheduled because of weather?
- Do outdoor headshots cost more than studio headshots?
When you're deciding between studio and outdoor headshots, start with where the photo will be seen. For most professionals that's a LinkedIn profile, a company team page, a conference program, or a casting submission, and in almost every case it appears smaller than a postage stamp. At that size, soft, controlled light and a clean background do more for you than a park, a skyline, or a brick wall.
I'm Aviva Sherman, and I've been photographing clients since 2016. At Aviva Sherman Photography, I photograph headshots under studio lighting, either in my West Ridge studio or set up in a client's conference room. Outdoor portraits have their uses, and I'll be specific about where they fit. For the headshot that represents you professionally, I recommend the studio, for reasons that come down to light and shadow, weather, wardrobe, consistency, and how the session feels when you'd rather not be photographed at all.
Key takeaways
- Soft light instead of hard sun: Large studio light sources close to your face wrap light around it, while direct sunlight throws hard-edged shadows and makes you squint.
- Shadows where they help: In the studio I decide where shadows fall, adding definition to the cheekbones and jaw and filling in the shadows under the eyes that make people look tired.
- Weather under control: You're indoors at a comfortable temperature, with no wind, rain, glare, or humidity to work around, and the session happens on the day you booked it.
- More clothing options: Any outfit works in any season, and changing between looks takes minutes.
- Readable at small sizes: A neutral background keeps attention on your expression at thumbnail size, which is how most people will see your headshot.
- Repeatable for teams: A studio setup can be recorded and rebuilt months later, so new hires match the rest of the team page.
- Easier for camera-shy clients: A private room and image review during the session make it easier to relax and to see that the photos are working.
- Outdoor as a supplement: Environmental images can add to a personal brand, and they work best alongside a studio headshot.
Lighting: The Biggest Difference Between Studio and Outdoor Headshots
In the studio, I decide where each light goes and how strong it is, and nothing changes until I change it. Outdoors, the sun makes those decisions for you.
Harsh sunlight vs soft studio light
Whether light is hard or soft depends on how big the source is compared to your face. The sun is enormous, but it's so far away that it behaves like a tiny point of light, and a small source throws shadows with sharp, dark edges. On a clear day that means a hard line under the nose and dark pockets in the eye sockets, with a shiny patch on the forehead and the tip of the nose. Hard light also skims across the skin and exaggerates texture, so pores and fine lines look deeper than they do in person.
Then there's the squint. Very few people can face bright sun without narrowing their eyes, and in a headshot a squint reads as tension.
Studio light works the other way. The panels I use are large and sit close to you, so the light wraps around the curves of your face and shadows fade out gradually instead of ending in a hard edge. Skin looks smoother before retouching even starts, and you aren't squinting into the sun.
Outdoor photographers soften sunlight by moving clients into open shade or scheduling near sunset, and both help. Shade still lights you mostly from above, though, which leaves the eyes darker than the rest of the face. The soft, low light near sunset lasts a short while and changes minute to minute.
Controlling shadows, and why studio light flatters the face
Shadows give a face its shape. A little shadow along the cheekbones and under the jaw adds definition, and too much in the wrong place adds years and fatigue. In the studio I can put shadow where it helps and keep it away from where it doesn't.
For most headshots I use two tall panels, one on each side of you, and a third below, angled up to fill in under the chin. The side panels shape the cheekbones and the sides of the face. The panel below lifts the shadows under the eyes and beneath the chin, which are the ones that make people look tired. Together they leave a small triangle of catchlights in your eyes, and those catchlights are a big part of why eyes look bright and alert in a studio headshot. Many of the women I photograph are over 40, and for them I think this is the most flattering setup there is, because it fills in fine lines and shadows instead of carving them deeper.
Small adjustments make a visible difference, and I make them during the session. Moving a light a few inches or turning your face slightly toward it changes how much definition the image shows. The angle of your chin changes where the shadow under your jaw falls, which is why I direct it throughout. Outdoors, the main light is fixed in the sky, and the only way to change the shadows is to move you.
What studio light does for skin tone
Daylight changes color through the day. It runs warm in the early morning and late afternoon and cool in shade, and it picks up color from whatever it reflects off. Stand on a lawn and some green ends up on your skin; stand next to red brick and you get a warm cast. Studio light holds the same color for the entire session, so your skin looks the same from one frame to the next, and my retouching goes into refining the image rather than correcting its color.
Does Weather Unpredictability Actually Cost You?
In Chicago it does.
The most flattering outdoor light lasts a short window early in the morning and late in the afternoon, and your schedule has to fit it. Wind pulls hair across faces and flips collars. Heat and humidity break down makeup and leave skin shiny within minutes. Popular spots come with pedestrians, traffic, and sometimes a permit requirement. A summer afternoon here can go from soft overcast to hard sun in half an hour, and between November and March the bigger question is whether you can stand outside long enough for your face to relax.
Any one of those can be managed. Together they lead to rescheduled dates and photos taken while you were squinting or rushing to finish before the light went.
Weather control in the studio
In the studio, the weather is something I control along with the light. You're indoors at a comfortable temperature, nothing blows your hair out of place after you've fixed it, and humidity isn't working on your makeup while we shoot. Your hair and makeup look the same in the last frame as they did in the first.
The session also happens when you booked it. Come in the morning or late afternoon, in July or January, and the light will be identical. Nobody checks the forecast the night before or moves the date because of a storm.
Clothing Options: Why the Studio Gives You More Choices
Outdoors, the weather picks part of your wardrobe. A wool blazer in August means sweating through the session, and a sleeveless dress in January isn't realistic. In the studio you can wear the wool suit or the sleeveless dress in any month, because the temperature stays comfortable.
Changing between outfits is easier too. I recommend bringing two or three, and in the studio switching looks takes a few minutes, with no hunting for a restroom near the location or changing in the back seat of a car. We look at each outfit on the screen as we shoot, so you'll know which one works best before the session is over. A blazer or jacket you can take off gives you two looks from one outfit.
What to wear for a studio headshot
Studio light shows fabric clearly, so solid colors and matte or low-sheen fabrics photograph best. Navy, charcoal, slate blue, and burgundy read as professional in almost any industry. Skip loud prints, neon, and pure white, and avoid thin stripes and tight patterns, which can create a rippling moiré effect on camera.
Have your hair done before you arrive. If you wear makeup, keep it close to your everyday look, just slightly more polished. Once you book, I send a confirmation email with guidance on wardrobe, hair, and makeup.
Outdoor sessions need more planning: layers for changing temperatures, blotting papers for heat and humidity, and colors chosen to stand apart from greenery or brick.
Background Options and What They Say About You
Your headshot will be seen most often at thumbnail size: next to a LinkedIn comment, in a search result, in a grid of faces on a team page. At that size a busy background competes with your face. Trees and buildings turn into patches of color around your head, and the viewer's eye has to hunt for you. A neutral backdrop leaves your face as the only thing to look at.
A plain backdrop also ages well. Gray or white doesn't tie you to a season or a location, so the photo stays current until your hair or your glasses change. Fall leaves behind you will read as fall every time someone opens your profile, including in June.
Outdoor and on-location settings do add context, and sometimes that context helps. A landscape designer photographed in a garden shows you what she does before you read a word. Images like that are useful on a website banner, an About page, or in a feature article. In the small square that represents you on LinkedIn or a company directory, the setting usually takes more attention than it gives back.
Why Consistency Matters More Than You Think
For a company, consistency is what makes a team page look like one organization. After every office session I record the setup: light positions, background, camera height, and crop. When someone joins in March, I can photograph them on that same setup, on a return visit or at my studio, and their headshot fits into the grid next to everyone else's.
Outdoor headshots can't be matched that way. Season, time of day, and weather all change the look, so a team page built from outdoor photos starts to drift as soon as the first new hire is photographed under a different sky.
The Studio Is Easier If You Dislike Being Photographed
Most of the people I photograph are professionals and women over 40, and many arrive uncomfortable around a camera. I don't enjoy being photographed either, so I know how it feels to stand there with no idea what your face is doing.
A studio is private. No one walks past while you're working on an expression, and there's no audience on the sidewalk. I direct the whole session, from posture and shoulders to hands, chin, and expression, so you never have to figure out how to pose. We review the images together on a screen as we go, which means anything that isn't working gets fixed on the spot, and you choose your favorites before you leave.
That kind of back-and-forth is harder outside. The photographer is often several yards away with a longer lens, watching the light and the location at the same time, and reviewing images means squinting at the back of a camera in the glare.
If the camera is the part you dread, my post on headshots for people who hate being photographed walks through what happens in a session.
Which Setting Fits Your Professional Goals?
Most headshots have a job to do, and the job decides the setting. The comparison below covers the most common uses.
Studio vs outdoor headshots by professional goal
| Professional goal | Better setting | Why |
|---|---|---|
| LinkedIn profile | Studio | A clean background and soft light stay readable at the small size LinkedIn displays. |
| Company team page or staff directory | Studio | The setup can be recorded and repeated, so new hires match. |
| Casting submission or agency profile | Studio | Nothing in the frame competes with your face and expression. |
| Speaker bio or conference program | Studio | Organizers crop and resize photos for programs, slides, and signage, and a plain background holds up through all of it. |
| Media kit or press release | Studio | Editors and designers can place a plain-background photo on almost any layout. |
| Author bio or byline | Studio | Bylines and book jackets print small, where a busy setting turns into clutter. |
| Most flattering light on mature skin | Studio | Soft, wrapping light fills in fine lines and under-eye shadows that hard sun deepens. |
| Several outfits in one session | Studio | Any outfit works in any season, and changing takes minutes. |
| A session date you can count on | Studio | Weather can't move it. |
| Personal brand for coaches and consultants | Studio first, outdoor as an add-on | A studio headshot anchors the brand, and environmental images can fill a website banner or social posts. |
| Lifestyle or creative brand imagery | Outdoor or on-location | When the setting is part of what you sell, it belongs in the frame. |
For most professionals the practical plan is a studio headshot for everything that represents you formally, with environmental images added later if your brand calls for them.
How Pricing and Session Structure Compare
Studio and outdoor sessions are often priced in a similar range. On-location and outdoor work can cost more once travel, equipment transport, setup and teardown, and a possible weather reschedule are figured in. My studio pricing is comparable to or better than downtown studios, and current session options are on my pricing page.
Before you compare two quotes, confirm what each one includes:
- The number of final retouched images
- Whether retouching is included in the price, and who does it
- Image usage rights, especially if a PR agency, speaking bureau, or marketing team will use the files
- The rescheduling policy, including who pays when weather cancels an outdoor session
A lower quote that leaves out any of these can end up costing more.
What to Ask a Photographer Before You Book
Whichever setting you choose, these questions will tell you most of what you need to know:
- Do you direct posing and expression for the entire session?
- Will I see my images during the session, or does the gallery arrive days later?
- How many retouched images are included, and who does the retouching?
- What happens if I don't like the photos?
- Who holds the usage rights, and can my PR team or speaking bureau use the files?
- For outdoor sessions, what's the weather policy, and who pays if we reschedule?
My own answers are short. I direct every session from the first frame to the last, and we review your images together before you leave. I retouch every image myself.
Studio Headshots in Chicago at Aviva Sherman Photography
If you need one headshot that works on LinkedIn, your company website, a conference program, and a press release, book it in a studio. You'll get soft light shaped for your face, shadows placed where they flatter you, a background that holds up at any size, and a session the weather can't touch.
Aviva Sherman Photography is set up for exactly that. Every session is fully directed, and you approve your images before you go home. The studio is in West Ridge, about 30 minutes from the Loop by car, with free parking. For teams, I bring the same lighting and backdrop to your office, so a conference room produces the same image quality as the studio.
Tell me where your photos will be used and when you need them, and I'll recommend the right session. You can book at avivasherman.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are studio headshots better than outdoor headshots?
For most professional uses, yes. Studio light is soft, controlled, and consistent, a neutral background stays readable at thumbnail size, and weather can't cancel the session. Outdoor and on-location images work well as a supplement for personal brands where the setting is part of the story.
Is studio lighting more flattering than natural light?
For most faces, yes. Direct sunlight is a hard light source that deepens wrinkles, darkens the eye sockets, and makes people squint. Large studio light sources placed close to the face wrap light around it, soften texture, and let the photographer decide where shadows fall, so the cheekbones and jaw get definition while under-eye shadows are filled in.
What should I wear for a studio headshot?
Bring two or three outfits in solid colors and matte or low-sheen fabrics. Navy, charcoal, slate blue, and burgundy work in almost any industry. Avoid loud prints, neon, and thin stripes. Because the studio stays at a comfortable temperature, you can wear what you'd actually wear to work in any season.
Do studio headshots look stiff?
They can, and so can outdoor ones. A stiff headshot almost always comes from a stiff expression, and that's a direction problem. When you're coached through posture and expression and can see the images as we go, a studio headshot looks warm and approachable.
Is a studio session a good choice if I hate having my picture taken?
It's the setting I'd recommend. The room is private, I direct every pose and expression, and you see your images during the session, so you're never left wondering how it's going.
Where can I get studio headshots in Chicago?
Aviva Sherman Photography offers fully directed studio headshot sessions in West Ridge, about 30 minutes from the Loop by car, with free parking. You review your images before you leave. For teams, the same studio lighting comes to your office.
Can you match a team's headshots when we add new employees?
Yes. I record the light positions, background,and crop after every office session, so new hires can be photographed on the same setup and match the rest of the team. Outdoor team photos are much harder to match because season, time of day, and weather all change the look.
Who pays if an outdoor session is rescheduled because of weather?
That depends on the photographer, so ask before booking and get the policy in writing, including any fees and deadlines. A studio session avoids the question entirely.
Do outdoor headshots cost more than studio headshots?
Often, though not always. Outdoor and on-location sessions can cost more once travel, equipment transport, and setup time are included. Confirm what each quote covers, including retouching and usage rights, before comparing prices.