Headshots

Headshots for People Who Hate Being Photographed, Like Me

By Aviva Sherman 5-minute read
Table of Contents

I don't like having my picture taken. I've felt that way my whole life, and I photograph people for a living.

Sometimes it's my nose and sometimes it's my weight. A camera is a great place to hide. I bought my first one at 54, and I'm still happier on this side of the lens.

So when someone walks into my studio in West Ridge and tells me they're terrible in photos, I believe they feel that way. I don't agree with the conclusion, though. Most people who tell me they're bad in front of a camera have just never been directed.

Why photos of you look wrong to you

Long before I picked up a camera, I was an electrologist, and I met a lot of people who didn't like what they saw in the mirror. The mirror is part of the trouble with photos, too.

You know your face from the mirror, which shows it flipped. A photo shows it the right way round. That's the face your coworkers and clients see every day, but you rarely see it, so it looks slightly off to you and you can't say why.

Phones make it worse. The main lens on a phone is about 26mm, which is wide, and you're holding it at arm's length, so whatever sits closest to it gets bigger. Usually that's your nose. Portrait lenses run from about 85mm to 135mm and work from farther back. I go into the details in my post on whether the camera really adds ten pounds.

Then there's timing. A snapshot gets taken whenever the other person is ready, mid-word or mid-blink, and nobody checks the frame before it goes into a group chat. A camera roll full of those would convince anyone they're unphotogenic. What it's showing you is the wrong lens, the wrong distance, and lighting nobody chose on purpose.

If cameras have never been kind to you, that's a lighting and lens problem. Mine to solve.

Why I never tell you to relax

Relaxing on command is impossible, and "just be natural" is the least natural instruction there is. "Smile!" is worse. It gets you the driver's license smile, the one your face makes while it waits for the flash.

I give you small directions instead. I'll tell you where to stand, where to look, and what to do with your hands, usually something as small as "chin forward a little" or "weight onto your back foot." You follow small directions, and the photo takes care of itself.

Expression is a different problem. A tight jaw doesn't loosen because someone asks it to. It loosens when you're thinking about something other than the camera. In one session I asked a client named Mark who his favorite super heroine was. He said Wonder Woman right away, which happens to be my answer too, and the smile that followed is the one in his final images. The conversation is where the expression comes from.

You'll see the photos while we're shooting

If you hate being photographed, the worst part might be not knowing. The shutter clicks, and you picture the worst possible version of that frame.

Every session I run includes real-time image review. The images come up on a screen as we go and we look at them together, so you can tell me what bothers you while there's still time to change it. You leave having seen your images, and the retouched files arrive in 3 to 5 business days.

There's no clock on a session, either. Some people need a while before they relax in front of a camera, and you won't be rushed. I don't expect much from the first few minutes. They're warm-up for both of us.

Retouching stays gentle: color correction, temporary blemishes removed, lines softened a bit. Skin should still look like skin, and your face should still look like your face. The moment I'm working toward is the one where someone looks at the screen and says, "That looks like me, and I love it."

What to ask before you book

Price matters. But if the camera is the part you dread, ask how the session works first:

  • What do you do when someone freezes up?
  • Will you tell me what to do, or am I expected to pose?
  • Can I see the images during the session?
  • Is there a time limit?
  • Who else will be in the room?

Listen for specifics. "I'll make you laugh" is nice to hear and doesn't tell you what happens if you don't. And if the answer to the second question is "just be natural," you'll be directing yourself.

My guide on how to choose a headshot photographer in Chicago covers portfolios and turnaround. For prices, see what professional headshots cost in Chicago.

Before you come in

Tell me what bothers you in photos of yourself. Your nose, your chin, a smile you think looks forced, the side you never show. I'd rather know before the first frame.

Wear something you've already worn to work and felt fine in. A brand-new outfit is one more thing to think about. If you can't decide, bring a few, since there's no limit on outfits. My post on what to wear for your professional headshot has more, and if you're a woman over 40, so does my guide to headshot photography for mature women.

And if you can, don't book it between two meetings. Arriving flustered only makes the warm-up longer.

Why I work this way

I've been encouraging people to see themselves differently since my electrology days. A headshot session gives me better tools for it: light I set up on purpose and a lens at the right distance, with a screen where you can watch it working. I was trained by Peter Hurley, and I still enter his Headshot Crew's weekly contest, which only accepts that week's work.

You're allowed to show up nervous. Since 2016 I've photographed hundreds of clients, and most of them arrived nervous. Getting a photo that looks like you is my job.

Frequently asked questions

Why do I look bad in photos but fine in the mirror?

The mirror flips your face and a photo doesn't, so photos show you a version of yourself you rarely see. A phone held close adds lens distortion on top of that. Neither one means you're unphotogenic.

Do I need to know how to pose for a headshot?

No. In my sessions I tell you where to stand, where to look and what to do with your hands, one small direction at a time.

How long is a headshot session if I need time to relax?

As long as it takes. There's no clock on my sessions, because some people need a while before they relax in front of a camera.

Scroll to Top